- 10.003 to the mountain-shadowed plains beyond,
This concept does not have an entry in OED, whether hyphenated or not.
This concept does not have an entry in OED, whether hyphenated or not.
Mountains have roots, but there is only one instance of “mountain-roots”.
Here are other forms of this concept:
The Roots of the Mountains: Wherein is Told Somewhat of the Lives of the Med of Burgdale, their Friends, Their Neighbors, Their Foemen, and Their Fellows-in-Arms, by William Morris, is the earliest that I know where to look for this idea. Famous Tolkien scholar Douglas A. Anderson reported that “Lewis writes that Tolkien ‘grew up on William Morris and George MacDonald.'” I am about to send a note to that eminent gentleman to ascertain his source. Update just two hours later – Dr. Anderson has kindly replied that “the quote comes from a CS Lewis letter to Arthur Greeves, dated 4 February 1933. It’s in They Stand Together (p. 449), and also (I suppose) the Collected Letters of CSL.” I will endeavor to put my hands on one book or the other forthwith.
Meanwhile, “mountain-root” by any spelling is not found in OED, so we will give it the JRRT tag. And by “we”, I mean “the dogs and I”.
Anderson, Douglas A. Personal correspondence. September 19, 2017. email.
Anderson, Douglas A. “Week 3 Friday Lecture.” Roots of the Mountain. Course for Signum University, lecture delivered September 12, 2014. Web.
Although “mountain path” has a sub-entry under “mountain” in OED, both the entry and all examples have a space, not a hyphen. I’m declaring this a JRRT original spelling.
A unique Tolkien-created way to put together this concept.
This wonderfully nuanced word is found in OED.
mountain king n.
1834 F. D. Hemans Songs of Captivity iv, in National Lyrics 168 I dream of some proud bird, A bright-eyed mountain king.1954 J. R. R. Tolkien Fellowship of Ring ii. x. 416 Like a lost child that had clambered upon the throne of mountain-kings.2000 World & I (Electronic ed.) 1 Nov. 167 Among the Lapps, it was said that the northern lights originated in a battle between the god Thor and the mountain king.
Since there are other examples before and after, I wonder how we count this one? I can see it both ways – and I will ask advice of you all in the blog, September 19, 2017.
UPDATE – Since the other examples do not have the hyphen, this is a JRRT original form of the word.
“mountain, n. and adj.” OED Online, Oxford University Press, June 2017, http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/122893. Accessed 19 September 2017.
Found nowhere in OED, a Tolkien original.
This two-word word is found in OED, and hyphenated in the examples.
“moss, n.1.” OED Online, Oxford University Press, June 2017, http://www.oed.com/view/Entry/122565. Accessed 19 September 2017.
These go completely unmentioned in OED, a true JRRT original.
It’s an old concept, but a new way of putting the words together, unattested in OED as a single word or compound word.
This is a new combination word, not in the OED.