This tinkle comes when Bilbo stumbles over a golden thing, therefore I give it a “low” tag, but the tinkle of broken glass upon the entry of a foe could have a very different register.
- 13.018 and a tinkle
This tinkle comes when Bilbo stumbles over a golden thing, therefore I give it a “low” tag, but the tinkle of broken glass upon the entry of a foe could have a very different register.
“Thump” is another word whose register depends on what is causing the thumping. Dwarves threaten to thump plates in Chapter 1 and trolls thump about in a slapstick fight scene in Chapter 2. While the mood is eerie in Chapter 8, the thumping of feet or of dwarves to the ground are clumsy and low in comparison to the menacing, listening place. In Chapter 9, Bilbo’s heart thumps during the daring rescue – but their danger is not particularly great.
“Thud” seems to be an onomatopoeic word the register of which depends on exactly what is doing the thudding. The feet of oliphaunts on their way to war? Dangerous and high. Barrels full of dwarves? Low.
Even though the idea of goblin poetry is rather jocular, I maintain that the onomoatopoeic words for dangerous things get the “high” tag.
Interesting. I believe in this context, the sound of “swish” is dangerous, therefore adventurous, and I will tag it “high”.
Bilbo’s stammer in Chapter 18 points out the distance between his station and Thranduil’s.
A squeal is another sound made by prey animals and vulnerable persona when in danger. Definitely “low”.
Things which squeak are obviously either funny or contemptible. Another “low” tag for an onomatopoeia word.
The Chapter 16 instance of “splutter” occurs when Bilbo stumbles and falls into a stream on his super-silent mission to reach Bard without the dwarves’ knowledge. Definitely a funny bit of slapstick. Johnson (of “Boswell’s Life of___” fame) called this a low word, and I’ll happily take that evidence.
“splutter, n.” OED Online. Oxford University Press, March 2015. Web. 20 May 2015.
Gollum hisses – definitely low. Spiders hiss – definitely low. Dwarves hiss in a stumbling about scene, also tagged “low”. In Chapter 14, however, the hisses are of dragon-fired arrows and bits of building falling into the lake. Same word, much more weighty feeling. I shall have to find a way to tag those two instances as “high”.
What do we think? Is “sss” a different word from “hiss”? Probably. We will have to revisit this word.